Therefore, to understand what al-Tabari wrote on page 111, one must ask a more critical question: The core of the controversy, therefore, is not al-Tabari’s writing, but the profound theological challenge the incident presents to the absolute preservation and purity of the Qur’anic revelation.
In the introduction of his Tarikh , al-Tabari explicitly warned readers that his book contained reports that some might find objectionable or false. He noted that he merely passed down what was narrated to him, leaving the critical evaluation of authenticity to the reader and future scholars.
The Treaty of Hudaybiyah, as described on , had far-reaching implications for the Muslim community. It symbolized a recognition of Islam's growing strength and the inevitability of Muhammad's prophethood. Moreover, the treaty facilitated the performance of Umrah (a pilgrimage to Mecca) by Muslims, which had been a long-standing desire of the Prophet and his followers. al tabari volume 6 page 111
On this page, Al-Tabari records a narration detailing a moment when the Prophet Muhammad was deeply eager to find a reconciliation with his tribe, the Quraysh, who had rejected his monotheistic message. According to the narrative found on :
In conclusion, is more than just a page in a historical manuscript; it is a window into the pivotal moments of human history. Through al-Tabari's meticulous documentation of events such as the Treaty of Hudaybiyah, readers gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of early Islamic history and the remarkable leadership of Prophet Muhammad. As scholars continue to study and translate al-Tabari's work, its significance and relevance only continue to grow, offering new insights into the challenges and triumphs of bygone eras. Therefore, to understand what al-Tabari wrote on page
: The polytheists of Mecca were delighted by this apparent approval of their gods and joined the Muslims in prostration. The "Confession" on Page 111 The specific text on
This passage remains one of the most heavily debated texts in Islamic history, polemics, and academic Islamic studies. The Historical Narrative on Page 111 The Treaty of Hudaybiyah, as described on ,
Depending on the specific printed edition and translation used, page 111 typically encompasses one of two specific Hadith (traditions) cited by Al-Tabari to illustrate the Quraysh's desperation.
Note: Pagination in classical texts can vary depending on the edition (Cairo, Beirut, or the SUNY English translation). The above content is developed based on the chronological placement of events in Volume 6 regarding the purge of the Umayyad family.
💡 : Most mainstream Islamic scholars and "Hadith" specialists consider this specific story of the "Satanic Verses" to be fabricated ( mawdu' ) or extremely weak ( da'if ), despite its presence in Al-Tabari's historical chronicle.
The following verses in the Surah, or subsequent revelation (Surah 22:52), are then cited to explain how God abrogated or removed those words, clarifying that the words were not from Him.